Quote Originally Posted by jeepster09 View Post
Definitely not for carry gun. Ahlman's gun shop does not recommend them. They replace tons of them due to being to fragile.

Some are definitely better than others. The one’s where the “pipe” is almost fully exposed... asking for trouble. Some have the pipe more protected as they are enveloped in metal. My buddy’s Taurus poly Judge pipe does not have anything enveloping it, and he is a klutz, so he breaks it often.
First 2 pics are what I’d call asking for it. 2nd 2 are better protected: